FIVE questions
you should
ask ...
Speak to one of our travel
within 5 rings

Which of these is important to you?

  • Concierge style service. Your own dedicated travel manager who'll look after you until you travel.
  • Better value. Exclusive fares you won't find online to save you money.
  • 24 hour helpline. A worldwide team just a phone call away if you need help while you're overseas.
  • Top on Trustpilot. More highly rated than all our competitors with 98% saying they'd book again.
  • Risk free. Fully licensed with Client Trust Account to protect your money. ABTA, ATOL protected.

Your calls always answered within 5 rings.

You've read the reviews so why not call us NOW?
Tell us what you need. We'll find you a solution
Caribbean Reviews 4291
Caribbean Offers 23
Barbados or Bequia

Barbados or Bequia

Hunter Davies heroically endures a fortnight of unrelenting Caribbean luxury to discover which of two idyllic islands comes out on top

I said I was never going to Barbados again - 29 consecutive years was quite enough, thank you. Bequia, the little Grenadine island a short hop away, was my new Caribbean love.

But when the time came for my annual trip to the West Indies, I thought: 'Hmm, can I really drop Barbados, after all we have been through?'  So I decided I would go to both Barbados and Bequia and rate the things that really matter to me on each island. Then, finally, I can make up my mind… 

Barbados is a much bigger island, with a population of 284,000, mostly well-off. It's well organised, safe and efficient, with much to see and do, modern facilities, the poshest, most luxurious hotels in the Caribbean, many wonderful restaurants plus all those celebs and footballers posing on the beaches.

A haven for yachts at Port Elizabeth in Bequia

Bequia is titchy in comparison, with a population of scarcely 5,000. It's just five miles long, with a laidback atmosphere, not to say a bit dozy and cut off - but a real, working island. There's little chance of a selfie with your favourite soap star here. It is a paradise for yachties, with hundreds of little boats dotting the enormous bay at Port Elizabeth, many of whom have just crossed the Atlantic. Little fleets of service and water taxis buzz back and forth, taking supplies. There's so much to watch.

The interior seems bigger than it is, with all the hills and peninsulas and hidden trails.

Catering for the British holidaymaker, Limegrove Mall in Holetown

On each island, I have a favourite place which for years I have walked to every afternoon to poke around, have a rum punch, stare at people, have a rum punch, talk to the locals, have a rum punch, convincing myself I am communing with the spirit of the island.

In Barbados, it is the little town of Speightstown, in the north, away from the glitter of the Holetown area. So many of Speightstown's shopfronts remind me of Carlisle in the 1950s.

Catch of the day at Bagatelle restaurant

In Bequia, there are two places I can poke around forever, never growing bored. Port Elizabeth, the harbour and island's only town, is fascinating and easy to walk to or from, with a newish walkway along the rocks from Princess Margaret Beach.

The other is Lower Bay, not a town as such, but hidden away along its wonderful beach there are three excellent restaurants, including Fernando's - run by Nando, a fisherman who catches his fish each morning, then cooks them in the evening. Then there are four cafe bars, Petra's grocery shop and Jacquie's organic fruit and veg haven.

As far as hotels are concerned there are ones at which I always stay, so my opinions are subjective. Since the Eighties I have gone at the same time every year to Cobblers Cove, luxurious but discreet and understated, with great food, beautiful gardens and nice suites.

In Bequia, I have moved around over the years, but I have settled on the Bequia Beach Hotel on Friendship Bay. It is so artistic, yet efficient, with big, stylish rooms. Like Cobblers, it appeals to the discerning. No vulgar TVs in the bedrooms. I should think not.

As well as having two restaurants on site Bequia Beach Hotel also owns the popular, cool, Jack’s Bar at Princess Margaret Beach which guests love. In Bequia I also know people who stay for months at a time in reasonably-priced apartments on Lower Bay - they're all regulars, snow birds from the UK and North America who become virtually locals for a large part of the year.

Elegant and discreet, Cobblers Cove offers luxury from the moment you arrive

One of the pleasures of Cobblers Cove is that it is like a house party, the same people staying at the same time, just like moi. And, of course, I love them all dearly. Oh yes.

So, how to choose? Well, both islands have superb if very different attractions. Barbados has so much to do. Bequia is so unspoiled.

From now on, should I just go to Bequia? However, I have decided to go to both islands again. Perhaps it will be my final time in Barbados. Perhaps not.

It will be my 30th year at Cobblers Cove, so naturally the reception desk staff will be holding up the Welcome Back flags. Anyway, I have paid my deposit for three nights' B&B - so I'm not going to lose that, am I?  

First published in the Mail on Sunday - November 2019

More articles below...

For more inspiration, read what travel writers have to say...

Sailing the high seas

Cruising the Windward islands proved just the ticket for Helen Atkinson Wood

Cuba's new revolution

One of the most fascinating holiday destinations, as Richard Eden discovered

Spicy Grenada

Renowned chef Rosemary Shrager discovers paradise on a plate

For sun and stars

Follow Wendy Gomersall to the beautiful Bahamas

Bliss in the BVIs

Vincent Graff discovers he can do without room keys and TVs

Chilling in Grenada

Samantha Lewis discovers the perfect island to relax

St Kitts and Nevis

Wendy Driver puts her best foot forward on a hiking trip

Caribbean cocktail

Grenada packs a punch, as Tamara Hinson discovers

Sun, sea and salsa!

The perfect partners for Bruno Tonioli

Authentic Cuba

John Hutchinson visits before the island nation changes forever

Bountiful Bequia

Nick Redman reports from the little Caribbean island of Bequia

Islands of treasure

There's so much more to the Cayman Islands than offshore banking says Sian Boyle

Chill out says Harriet Sime

With new direct flights, it's never been easier to relax in the Turks and Caicos

Marvellous Mustique

Mustique may be pricey but Kate Silverton discovers its laid-back glamour

The barmy Bahamas

Swimming with sharks and eating pickled lamb's tongue are just two of Mark Porter's highlights

Stunned by St Lucia

Marina Fogle is dazzled by this corner of the Caribbean

Happy hour

Stephen Macdonald samples deadly cocktails in Jamaica

Art beneath the waves

Rob Crossan discovers sublime beauty in this stunning underwater sculpture gallery

Past Perfect

Tristan Davies finds himself in a luxurious time capsule

Serene St Lucia

Ben Bailey finds paradise on gorgeous St Lucia

Get fit in paradise

Toni Jones signed up for sun, sea, sand and floating yoga

Bountiful Barbados

Jack Davidson discovers the island’s greatest treasure

Paradise on a plate

The fabulous food of Anguilla has Harry Denning’s tastebuds tingling

In love with St Lucia

Josh Cuthbert, of boy band Union J, knew there was only one place he wanted to celebrate his engagement

Best of Barbados

Fred Mawer's top tips to enjoy this fabulous Caribbean island

Gourmet gala

Jason Arnold delights in the culinary treats of Antigua and St Lucia

Caribbean heaven

Mark Palmer revels in two luxury resorts in the Dominican Republic

Bowled over by Bequia

Jonathan Agnew unearths a secret Windies gem

Rock and Royalty

Nigel Tisdall tells you how you can join the St Barths' jet-set

Besotted with Barbados

Sam Tonkin loves everything about this Caribbean idyll


Piers Morgan's favourite Caribbean hotel is better than ever

St Lucian sounds

Nigel Tisdall is dancing to a different beat in St Lucia

Batting for Antigua

The Caribbean just bowls you over says Mark Palmer

Plantation houses

Discover the Caribbean's historic hotels

Shifting Sands

James Henderson finds the Dominican Republic is quietly moving upmarket

The Dominican dream

Max Davidson discovers the most popular destination in the Caribbean

Not quite what you're looking for?
We can easily customise an offer to suit your exact requirements